A short guide to writing mystery

The mystery genre has captivated readers for centuries with its intriguing puzzles, enigmatic detectives, and nail-biting suspense. To write an effective mystery story, it is crucial to understand the genre's conventions and obligatory scenes. In this guide, we will explore the key elements of mystery writing and provide tips on crafting a compelling and engaging tale.

What is the mystery genre?

The mystery genre is a type of fiction that involves solving a puzzle or crime, typically through the perspective of a detective or amateur sleuth. These stories often utilize suspense, clues, and red herrings to keep the reader engaged and guessing until the conclusion.

The mystery genre is one of the external content genres, which focuses on the external conflicts and events that drive the story. Understanding this genre is essential for writers because it helps them develop stories that meet reader expectations and deliver a satisfying experience.

When to choose the mystery genre

If you're interested in crafting a story that revolves around an enigma, puzzle, or crime that needs to be solved, the mystery genre is an ideal choice. Mystery stories appeal to readers who enjoy trying to solve the puzzle alongside the protagonist, as well as those who appreciate the intellectual challenge and suspense that comes with uncovering hidden truths.

Key conventions of the mystery genre

To write an effective mystery story, it is crucial to incorporate the following conventions:

• The central enigma or puzzle: At the heart of every mystery story is a puzzle that needs to be solved. This could be a crime, a disappearance, or any other unexplained event that piques the reader's curiosity.
• The detective or sleuth character: The protagonist in a mystery story is typically a detective or amateur sleuth who takes on the task of solving the enigma. This character should be skilled at uncovering clues and possess keen observational and deductive abilities.
• The presence of clues and red herrings: To keep readers engaged, mystery stories should be filled with both genuine clues that lead to the solution and red herrings that mislead the reader and the detective.
• Suspense and tension throughout the story: A successful mystery story maintains a sense of suspense and tension as the detective gets closer to solving the puzzle and the stakes become higher.
• The final reveal or solution to the mystery: The climax of a mystery story should provide a satisfying resolution, as the detective reveals the solution to the enigma and unravels any remaining loose ends.

Obligatory scenes in the mystery genre

Incorporating the following obligatory scenes is essential to crafting a successful mystery story:

• The discovery of the crime or mystery: The story should begin with the introduction of the enigma, setting the stage for the detective's investigation.
• The introduction of the detective or sleuth: Early in the story, the protagonist should be introduced, and their motivation for solving the mystery should be established.
• The investigation and questioning of suspects: The detective will gather information, interview witnesses, and analyze clues, often encountering multiple suspects along the way.
• The uncovering of clues and the elimination of suspects: As the investigation progresses, the detective will piece together the puzzle, eliminating suspects and uncovering new leads.
• The climactic confrontation between the detective and the culprit: In the story's climax, the detective should confront the culprit, revealing their identity and the motives behind their actions.
• The resolution and explanation of the mystery: The final scene should tie up any loose ends and provide a satisfying resolution to the story.

Tips for writing an engaging mystery story

To craft a gripping mystery story, keep the following tips in mind:

• Start with a strong hook to capture readers' interest and immerse them in the enigma.
• Develop well-rounded characters, including a memorable detective or sleuth with a unique personality and backstory, as well as intriguing suspects with their own motives and secrets.
• Pace your story effectively by balancing moments of high suspense with quieter scenes that allow readers to absorb information and ponder the clues.
• Plant clues and red herrings strategically throughout your story, ensuring that they are subtly woven into the narrative and don't feel forced or contrived.
• Create a sense of atmosphere by using vivid descriptions of settings, evoking a mood that complements the tone of your mystery.
• Ensure your story's resolution is surprising yet plausible, rewarding readers for their investment in the mystery with a satisfying and unexpected conclusion.

The mystery genre offers writers the opportunity to craft intriguing stories that are full of suspense, intrigue, and intellectual challenges. By learning the important conventions and scenes expected in this genre and incorporating the advice provided in this guide, you can write a captivating mystery story that will keep readers guessing until the very end.

--

References

1. Coyne, Shawn. 2015. The Story Grid. New York, NY: Black Irish Entertainment.

‍