Everything you need to know about editing a crime fiction manuscript

Editing a crime fiction manuscript can feel like trying to solve a complex jigsaw puzzle – every piece needs to fit just right to reveal the full picture. But don't worry, this guide will be your trusty detective, helping you navigate the intricate process of crafting a tightly-woven, compelling crime narrative. Grab your magnifying glass and let's delve into the world of alibis, motives, and plot twists!

Understanding the audience

Crime fiction readers are a discerning lot. They love a good mystery, be it a hard-boiled detective story, a fast-paced thriller, a chilling crime horror, or a cosy murder mystery. They expect suspense, twists, intricate plots that keep them guessing, detailed investigations, and the thrill of solving the crime alongside the protagonist. When editing, ensure the procedural details are accurate, the clues are fair, and the resolution is satisfying.

Story structure and plot

In crime fiction, the story structure is all about the investigation. Ensure that the plot unfolds in a way that reveals clues, builds suspense, and leads to a satisfactory resolution of the crime. You need a gripping beginning, a middle full of suspense and escalating tension, and a satisfying ending that ties up all loose ends.

Character development

Your characters, particularly your detective and your villain, are central to your crime story. Readers should be drawn to your protagonist and intrigued by your antagonist.

In crime fiction, character development is steeped in unveiling layers of personality and hidden motives. Pay close attention to whether your characters unravel in a manner that adds depth and keeps the reader guessing.

Language and dialogue

Crime fiction often uses precise, factual language to create a sense of realism. Dialogue should reflect the professional nature of the characters, often including jargon related to law enforcement or criminal activity.

Your writing needs to show, not tell. Remember, your readers are here for a gripping mystery – don't let sloppy language or awkward dialogue spoil the suspense.

Theme and message

In crime fiction, themes often revolve around justice, morality, and the human condition. These themes and messages can add depth to your crime fiction story, providing commentary or sparking thought about societal issues or human nature.

As an editor, ensure these themes are deeply embedded in the plot and characters, enriching the narrative and providing a thought-provoking undercurrent to the suspenseful surface story. A thought-provoking theme can elevate your crime fiction from a simple mystery to a compelling exploration of human complexity.

Plotting a crime and resolution

Plotting a believable crime and a satisfying resolution is crucial in crime fiction. Your readers are playing detective alongside your protagonist, so your crime and its resolution must be clever and convincing.

In your edit, scrutinise your crime and resolution. Are they complex enough to engage your readers, yet plausible enough to not break their suspension of disbelief? Are all loose ends tied up by the end? Remember, a satisfying resolution is the key to a memorable crime fiction story.

The importance of editing in crime fiction

Editing a crime fiction manuscript is a meticulous process. It's about ensuring every detail, every clue, every character, and every scene contributes to the overall mystery and its resolution. When done right, you'll have a crime story that keeps readers on the edge of their seats, eagerly turning pages until the very end.

‍