How to reconcile feedback from a beta reader

Just imagine – you've received feedback from your beta reader, and it feels like you've been handed a mixed bag of chocolates – some sweet, some bitter, and some downright confusing. You're not alone. Reconciling feedback from a beta reader can be a challenging, yet incredibly rewarding part of the writing process. So let's dive in, shall we?

Understanding your beta reader's role

First, it's important to remember what a beta reader is and what they're not. They are not professional editors but enthusiastic readers who can provide a fresh perspective on your manuscript. Their role is to give you an idea of how readers might receive your story once it's published.

Appreciating the mix: Positive and negative feedback

Like the assorted chocolates in our metaphor, feedback often comes in a mix of positive and negative comments. Embrace the positive – it's a validation of your hard work! As for the negative or critical comments, remember that they are not a reflection on you as a person or writer but pointers towards areas of your work that might need improvement.

Deciphering the feedback

Now comes the part where you sift through the feedback. Here, it's essential to stay objective. Take your time and go through the input multiple times if needed. Try to understand the perspective of your beta reader. Ask for clarification if something is unclear – they're usually more than willing to explain their thoughts.

Prioritising changes

With all the feedback, the thought of making changes can be overwhelming. This is where prioritising becomes crucial. Identify which changes will significantly enhance your story and focus on those first. Changes could be prioritised based on plot development, character arcs, pacing, or even grammar and punctuation.

Balancing feedback with your vision

Feedback is invaluable, but it's essential to balance it with your vision for your story. You are the writer, after all. If a piece of feedback doesn't align with your vision, it's okay not to incorporate it. Writing is subjective; what doesn't work for one reader might work for others.

Implementing the changes

Once you've prioritised and balanced the feedback, it's time to roll up your sleeves and start editing. This can be a time-consuming process, so be patient with yourself. Remember, every edit is a step towards a better manuscript.

Reflecting on the process

Once you've gone through the process of reconciling and implementing feedback, take a moment to reflect. What did you learn? Which feedback was most beneficial? How can this process improve your future writing? Reflection is a powerful tool for growth as a writer.

The treasure in feedback

Reconciling feedback from a beta reader can be like going through a bag of mixed chocolates – you might find some you love, some you dislike, and some that surprise you. But each piece of feedback, whether sweet or bitter, is a treasure that can help you grow as a writer and refine your manuscript. So embrace the process, learn from it, and remember, every piece of feedback takes you one step closer to a polished, reader-ready manuscript.

‍