Everything you need to know about editing a mystery manuscript

Editing a mystery manuscript can sometimes feel like trying to decipher an ancient code – each symbol, each phrase, each punctuation mark holds a secret that could unravel the whole enigma. But don't fret, dear code-breaker! This guide is your own personal Rosetta Stone, helping you decode the mysteries of crafting a tantalising, page-turning whodunit. So, grab your notepad and let's dive into the clandestine world of clues, suspects, and unexpected twists!

Understanding the audience

Mystery readers are puzzle solvers. They enjoy intrigue, piecing together clues, suspecting various characters, and the satisfaction of a surprising yet logical reveal. They love a perplexing whodunit, a suspenseful psychological mystery, or an atmospheric gothic tale.

When editing, ensure that the mystery is intriguing, the pacing is suspenseful, and the conclusion is rewarding.

Story structure and plot

Mystery stories thrive on suspense and intrigue and this is achieved with careful plotting. The plot structure should be designed to hold the reader's curiosity, with the mystery deepening before it unravels, leading to an unexpected yet logical resolution.

Character development

Your characters, especially your sleuth and your perpetrator, are the lifeblood of your mystery. They must be complex, compelling, and capable of keeping your readers invested.

Mystery stories often hinge on the evolution of characters amidst the intrigue. It's essential that each character's transformation or revelation contributes to the suspense and resolution of the plot.

Language and dialogue

Mystery stories often use language that is suspenseful and intriguing. Dialogue reveals character insights and should be filled with clues and red herrings, helping to deepen the mystery and engage readers.

When editing, examine your language and dialogue. Is your language atmospheric and appropriate for the genre? Does your dialogue feel authentic and purposeful? Good language and dialogue can enhance the enigma and keep your readers hooked.

Theme and message

While the mystery itself is the main focus, underlying themes or messages can add depth to your story. This could be anything from exploring human nature (like truth, or the human capacity for receipt) to commenting on societal issues (like justice).

During your edit, ensure that the core mystery serves as a vehicle for these themes, providing a deeper layer of meaning beneath the who-done-it surface plot.

Crafting a compelling mystery and resolution

A compelling mystery and a satisfying resolution are the cornerstones of mystery fiction. Your mystery should be intriguing and your resolution should be surprising, yet retrospectively inevitable.

In your edit, scrutinise your mystery and resolution. Are they engaging, clever, and plausible? Are all questions answered by the end? A well-crafted mystery and resolution can make your novel a page-turner.

The importance of editing in mystery literature

Editing a mystery manuscript is akin to being an illusionist – your craft lies in misdirection, keeping your audience entranced and guessing until the grand reveal. By paying attention to every clue, every character, every plot twist, you create a tantalising illusion that lasts until the final curtain falls, when all is revealed to have been an intricately designed act. And isn't that just the kind of mystery that keeps readers coming back for more?

‍